The Substack Independent Writer

“What was the moment this product clicked?” — share yours

A journalist, essayist, researcher, or domain expert who chose to publish directly to an audience rather than through a publication that owns the relationship. They've been on Substack for 1–4 years. They have a free list and a paid tier. They take the writing seriously. They also think about the business of the writing — open rates, growth, conversion from free to paid — more than they expected to when they started. They are doing something that didn't exist at scale five years ago and they feel the weight and freedom of that simultaneously.

• →Write things that are good enough that readers stay and pay
• →Grow the free list without the growth feeling like it's warping the writing
• →Convert enough free readers to paid that the economics make sense

• —Discoverability that depends heavily on existing audience size — the cold start is real
• —Notes and Substack social features that require social media behavior from writers
• —who chose this specifically to avoid social media behavior
• —The psychological difficulty of emailing 4,000 people and measuring how many opened it
• —Analytics granular enough to optimize but not clear enough to act on

• The relationship with readers is the asset — it's not owned by a platform, an editor, or an algorithm
• Quality is the only sustainable distribution strategy
• The writing has to serve the reader first and the growth metrics second,
• or eventually it serves neither

Publishes weekly or biweekly. Uses Substack's editor as their primary writing environment. Sends a mix of free and paywalled posts. Manages their list themselves — no VA, no team. Occasionally uses Substack Chat. Has thought about launching a paid podcast on Substack but hasn't. Checks analytics after every send. Has been approached about partnerships or sponsored posts. Has turned most of them down. Has a clear sense of what they will and won't write about and why.

• →Recommendation network that surfaces new writers to relevant audiences removes the
• →cold start without requiring social media behavior
• →Analytics that explain performance without requiring the writer to optimize for metrics
• →give context without creating distortion
• →Flexible paywall models — per-post, archive access, founding member — give writers
• →more ways to structure the paid relationship beyond the single subscription tier
• →Writing tools (focus mode, rich formatting, pull quotes) that match the quality
• →of the writing reduce the friction between what they intend and what gets published

Pairs with `beehiiv-primary-user` to map the writer-first vs. publisher-as-operator Substack vs. Beehiiv philosophy. Contrast with `mailchimp-primary-user` for the audience-as-business vs. audience-as-distribution-list distinction. Use with `ghost-primary-user` for writers comparing owned publishing infrastructure vs. platform-hosted.